Renowned Pumpkin Pie for the Holidays

The Pumpkin Pie from William Greenberg Desserts is a creamy pumpkin custard, warmly spiced with cinnamon, ginger and cloves, baked in a rich all-butter crust. It is made for the holiday season and available for pick-up or delivery in New York City.

Each pie is made in our bakery from start to finish, so it comes to the table ready to serve. For a Thanksgiving dessert table, many customers order it alongside our sweet potato pie.

Details

• Sizes: 8 inch, 10 inch, and 12 inch
• Pumpkin custard spiced with cinnamon, ginger and cloves
• All-butter crust
• Baked in Manhattan
• Kosher certified
• Order by phone for local pick-up or delivery in New York City

To order, call 212-861-1340 (Upper East Side) or 212-865-2621 (Upper West Side). Please order at least two days ahead.

Can't decide? Try our Sweet Potato Pie, or see all of our pies. Sending a gift outside New York? Our nationwide shipping collection includes pecan, mince and fruit pies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What sizes does the pumpkin pie come in?

The pie comes in three sizes: 8 inch ($33), 10 inch ($48), and 12 inch ($73).

How do I order the pumpkin pie?

The pumpkin pie is ordered by phone for local pick-up or delivery in New York City. Call our Upper East Side bakery at 212-861-1340 or our Upper West Side bakery at 212-865-2621. Please order at least two days ahead.

Do you ship the pumpkin pie?

No. The pumpkin pie is available for pick-up or delivery in New York City only. For desserts that ship nationwide, see our nationwide shipping collection.

What spices are in the pumpkin pie?

Our pumpkin custard is spiced with cinnamon, ginger and cloves.

How should I store pumpkin pie?

Keep it covered in the refrigerator, since the filling is a custard.

Is the pumpkin pie kosher?

Yes. William Greenberg Desserts is a kosher-certified bakery, and every pumpkin pie is baked in our kitchen in Manhattan.