For Thanksgiving, William Greenberg Desserts bakes two kinds of seasonal cookies. Our Thanksgiving shortbreads are hand-decorated in the shapes of autumn leaves, pumpkins, acorns, and apples. Our Black & Whites come in Thanksgiving colors and in pumpkin and sweet potato flavors. All are available for a limited time, through Thanksgiving, online and at our Manhattan bakeries, 1100 Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side and 285 Amsterdam Avenue on the Upper West Side.
Thanksgiving Shortbread Cookies
Our buttery shortbread is cut into four fall shapes and decorated by hand:
- Autumn leaves in golden yellow, with veins piped in brown
- Pumpkins in bright orange, with green stems
- Acorns in warm brown, with crosshatched caps
- Apples in red, with a green leaf
Each box holds 12 cookies for $39. They have a delicate, buttery crumble, and they ship nationwide. Shop Thanksgiving Shortbreads
Thanksgiving Black & Whites
Our signature Black & White Cookies, with their cakey texture and rich chocolate and vanilla frosting, iced in orange, brown, and white for the holiday. Each gift package holds 18 minis for $40.50. Shop Thanksgiving Black & Whites
Pumpkin Black & Whites
Warmly spiced and finished with cream cheese frosting, a seasonal take on the cookie that made us famous. Shop Pumpkin Black & Whites
Sweet Potato Black & Whites
Sweet potato and holiday spices are swirled into our cake-like batter. This is a customer favorite, available for the season only. Shop Sweet Potato Black & Whites
Both flavors come in a mini box for $27 or a large box for $54. For more on the seasonal flavors, read Not Everything in Life is Pure Black & White.
Ways to Use Them
- Place cards: set a leaf or pumpkin shortbread at each seat.
- The kids' table: shortbread shapes give children something to look forward to between courses.
- A host gift: a box of Thanksgiving Black & Whites travels well and arrives ready to share.
- The dessert table: add a plate of cookies next to the pies for guests who want a smaller bite.
Planning the rest of the weekend? Read How Many Pies Do You Need for Thanksgiving? and Breakfast for the Day After Thanksgiving.
Frequently Asked Questions
What shapes are the Thanksgiving shortbread cookies?
William Greenberg Desserts Thanksgiving shortbreads are hand-decorated in four fall shapes: autumn leaves, pumpkins, acorns, and apples.
How many cookies come in a box?
Thanksgiving shortbreads come 12 to a box. Thanksgiving Black & Whites come in a gift package of 18 minis.
What flavors are the seasonal Black & Whites?
Pumpkin Black & Whites are spiced and finished with cream cheese frosting. Sweet Potato Black & Whites have sweet potato and holiday spices swirled into the batter. Thanksgiving Black & Whites are the classic cookie in orange, brown, and white.
Do the Thanksgiving cookies ship?
Yes. The Thanksgiving shortbread cookies ship nationwide.
When are the Thanksgiving cookies available?
The seasonal cookies are available for a limited time through Thanksgiving, online and at both William Greenberg Desserts bakeries, at 1100 Madison Avenue and 285 Amsterdam Avenue.
How much are the Thanksgiving cookies?
A box of 12 Thanksgiving shortbreads is $39. Thanksgiving Black & Whites are $40.50 for 18 minis, and Pumpkin and Sweet Potato Black & Whites are $27 for a mini box or $54 for a large box.