Caramel Cake

Our Caramel Cake is a delightful curiosity in our Manhattan bakery—a Southern dessert tradition that has found an enthusiastic New York audience. This conversation-starting cake draws daily attention from intrigued customers who are captivated by its distinctive appearance and irresistible flavor combination.

The star of this beloved creation is our butterscotch icing—a rich, smooth sauce crafted from light brown sugar, creamy butter, and evaporated milk that covers the cake. Each slice reveals perfect yellow cake layers, creating the ideal foundation for this distinctive Southern treat.

What truly sets this cake apart is the magnificent contrast between the sweet caramel coating loaded with toasty, crunchy almonds that adorn the exterior. 

For those seeking something beyond traditional New York desserts, our Southern-style Caramel Cake offers a delicious departure from the expected—a taste of Southern hospitality with William Greenberg's legendary Manhattan craftsmanship.

Available for local pickup at our Madison Avenue and Amsterdam Avenue locations or local Manhattan delivery. Please call us for special sizes and custom designs for your celebration.